Goodman AC VS. Comfortmaker: Which Is Better?

When it comes to selecting an air conditioner that balances energy efficiency and affordability, two prominent names in the market stand out: Comfortmaker and Goodman. As a homeowner, choosing the right air conditioning system can be a daunting task, given the plethora of options available. To help you make an informed decision, we have conducted an in-depth analysis of these two brands.

Comfortmaker’s Impressive SEER Ratings

One of the key factors in evaluating air conditioner efficiency is the SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) rating. Comfortmaker’s units boast impressive SEER ratings, with some models reaching up to 19 SEER. This places them ahead of Goodman’s top model in terms of energy efficiency. Notably, both Comfortmaker and Goodman offer a range of options, catering to those seeking entry-level systems as well as those aiming for high energy efficiency. Seeking advice from a professional contractor can significantly aid in choosing the most suitable option for your needs.

Deciphering The Models: Goodman vs. Comfortmaker

When delving into the specifics of each brand, it’s evident that both Goodman and Comfortmaker offer reliable and efficient air conditioning units. Even though prioritizing the most energy-efficient unit is advisable, budget constraints might limit this choice. Both brands offer middle-range models with solid warranties that provide reasonable efficiency and reliability.

For Goodman, the DSXC18 stands out as the most energy-efficient option, featuring a dual-stage compressor for smooth and quiet operation. Its price, including installation, ranges from approximately $3,500 to $7,000. On the other end, the GSC13 is Goodman’s less efficient model, with prices ranging from $2,000 to $5,500, and a five-year warranty.

Comfortmaker’s mid-tier offering, the SoftSound SX 2600, is comparable to Goodman’s DSXC16. With a SEER rating of 16, this Comfortmaker model comes with a price tag of around $3,000, including installation. Notably, it provides a ten-year warranty for both compressor and parts.

Advantages Of Choosing Comfortmaker

When weighing the options, Comfortmaker holds an edge over Goodman. The brand boasts units with a maximum SEER rating of 19, indicating superior energy efficiency compared to Goodman’s top model. It’s essential to note that higher energy efficiency often translates to a higher upfront cost. Additionally, if you reside in a region with mild winters and moderate summers, considering a heat pump might be a prudent choice.

The Department of Energy’s research underscores the energy-saving potential of heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems. Both Comfortmaker and Goodman cater to areas with hot and humid climates, offering affordable yet efficient air conditioning solutions that can contribute to reduced energy consumption.

Lifespan And Sizing Considerations

The longevity of an air conditioning unit depends on factors such as usage frequency and local climate. Comfortmaker units typically last between 15 to 25 years, while Goodman units have a lifespan of 10 to 15 years. Planning for eventual replacement is crucial, even with efficient systems.

Selecting the right size of an air conditioner for your home is equally vital. A professional installation ensures optimal performance. The capacity of an AC system is measured in tons, and for a 1,800 square foot house, a 3-ton unit, costing approximately $3,800 including installation, is recommended.

Behind The Brands: Makers Of Goodman And Comfortmaker

Goodman AC is manufactured by Goodman Manufacturing, an independent subsidiary of Daikin Group, the world’s largest HVAC producer. Comfortmaker, owned by International Cooling Products (ICP), a United Technologies Corporation (UTC) subsidiary, offers hassle-free replacements and robust warranties. Comfortmaker’s revenue hovers around $48.9 million, with a dedicated workforce of around 550 employees.

A Legacy Of Excellence

Comfortmaker Air Conditioning & Heating boasts a century-long legacy of serving communities. Parent company United Technologies oversees well-known brands like Carrier and Bryant. On the other hand, Goodman Air Conditioning, founded in 1975, is recognized for providing cost-effective heating and cooling solutions globally.

Noise Levels And Maintenance

While energy efficiency is paramount, noise levels matter too. Goodman air conditioners generate around 40 decibels during regular operation, rising to 70 decibels under stress. Regular maintenance of crucial components like the condensate drain and coils ensures consistent performance.

Reliable And Efficient Choices

Both Goodman and Comfortmaker offer reliable and efficient air conditioning systems. Their high SEER ratings and mid-tier models strike a balance between cost and efficiency. Comfortmaker’s edge in SEER ratings makes it a preferred choice for those seeking higher energy efficiency.

In Conclusion

When choosing between Goodman AC and Comfortmaker, energy-conscious consumers can confidently opt for either brand. Both offer models with the potential to save energy, some even carrying the ENERGY STAR certification. While Comfortmaker’s superior SEER ratings give it an edge, Goodman’s range of reliable options ensures there’s something for every budget and requirement. Through careful consideration and professional guidance, you can make a choice that keeps your home cool and your energy bills in check.