Carrier vs. Payne: Which Brand Has A Better HVAC System?

Having trouble deciding between Payne and Carrier for your furnace, heat pump, or air conditioner needs?

Carrier often has high-end versions if you’re searching for increased efficiency and a quiet cooling or heating system. However, Payne is a good option if you’re looking for something inexpensive because they have good products. A 10-year warranty is offered by both businesses.

We’ll discuss a few of Payne and Carrier’s top goods in this article. We’ll also discuss some of the costs, warranties, and features of their goods in an effort to aid you in making the best choice.

Carrier vs. Payne

Carrier has established a reputation for producing the best heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems for more than a century.

It offers a number of unique innovations that are said to increase the energy efficiency of its heat pumps, air conditioners, and furnaces.

However, United Technologies, a well-known and respectable producer of air conditioners that also makes Carrier, makes Payne as one of its brands.

Payne is a bargain brand, meaning that it has less features than high-end Carrier versions. The internal parts of each unit are nearly identical to those of Carrier, therefore the cost is fair and each unit represents outstanding value.

Product Categories And Models By Payne And Carrier

Products from Payne and Carrier include furnaces, heat pumps, and cooling systems. These systems are altered to satisfy user requirements and preferences. You can get the following HVAC units from Payne and Carrier:

Air Conditioners

The long-lasting air conditioners from Payne and Carrier are designed to keep their clients cool during the scorching summer.

Payne:
For increased comfort and energy efficiency, this brand offers freestanding units as well as units connected to a furnace or a fan coil.

The top-tier 17 PA17NA central air conditioner comes with a two-stage compressor for improved temperature and summer humidity management and has gained the ENERGY STAR certification.

Its sturdy exterior has a tight wire grill that helps protect it from weather damage. Additionally, it has a cooling efficacy seasonal energy efficiency ratio (SEER) of 17 and the lowest sound level of 73 decibels.

In order to save energy, it only operates at 25% of its maximum capability. Additionally, using R-410A refrigerant doesn’t deplete the ozone layer. The Payne air conditioners have the following characteristics:

• SEER 13-17
• EER 11–12.2: Energy Efficiency Ratio
• The Energy Star label
• Sound levels as low as 73 decibels
• Functioning of single-stage compression

Carrier:

In the business, Carrier air conditioners are among the most effective and silent. Due to its inverter-driven, variable-speed compressor that is intended to run almost constantly, its flagship 24VNA type has a rating of 26-SEER.

It maintains a more consistent temperature as a result of this compressor. Additionally, because of its improved sound blanket, it can operate at a noise level as low as 51 dB. The following features of air conditioners made by Carrier:

• SEER scores as high as 26
• Sound levels as low as 51 decibels
• Compressors made by Copeland that have one, two, and variable speeds.
• In some models, air filtration is provided.

Heat Pumps

The right Payne or Carrier heat pump will keep your house warm during the frigid winter nights.

Payne:
Users can enjoy unrivaled comfort and energy efficiency with Payne heat pumps. The PH16NA is the only two-stage conventional heat pump produced by Payne, and by carefully regulating the temperature and humidity levels, it improves indoor comfort.

It has a 9.5 HSPF and a 17 SEER rating. Like other conventional Payne heat pumps, the PH16NA is completely compatible with Payne gas furnaces for increased heating capacity. The numerous features of Payne’s heat pump include:

• SEER scores as high as 17
• EER scores as high as 13.3
• Up to 9.5 Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF) ratings
• Sound levels as low as 69 decibels
• Operation of a two- or one-stage compressor

Carrier:
Carrier’s product ranges are comparable, despite the fact that there are 11 less heat pumps than air conditioners (16 in total). Like its top-tier air conditioner, the top-tier Carrier 25VNA4 heat pump incorporates Greenspeed Intelligence to help maintain the home’s temperature and a sound level as low as 51 decibels.

There are versions in every price level, including the 25HCE4, which is less expensive and offers basic comfort amenities with Carrier quality. Some characteristics of heat pumps made by Carrier include the following:

• SEER scores as high as 24
• HSPF rankings as high as 13.
• Sound levels as low as 51 decibels
• Compressors made by Copeland that have one, two, and variable speeds.

Furnaces

Payne:
The top-of-the-line furnace from Payne is the 96 PG96VTA, an ENERGY STAR-certified unit with AFUE ratings as high as 96 percent.

It provides reliable comfort at a reasonable cost. The compatibility of the cabinet with an air purifier and humidifier enhances the quality of the air within your house, and the highly insulated cabinet ensures steady heat transfer to your ducting.

Due to its adaptable two-stage operation, Payne’s line of high-quality furnaces will surely keep your home warm and comfy throughout even the toughest winters. Payne heat pumps have the following features, for example:

• Ratings of 92.1 to 96% for Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE)
• The Energy Star label
• Value of a two- or one-stage gas

Carrier:
There are numerous models available for the Infinity, Performance, and Comfort lines of furnaces from Carrier. The most advanced furnace under this brand is the 59MN7. Its AFUE rating of 98.5 percent means that the majority of the fuel it consumes is turned into heat.

While most of the furnaces made by Carrier only use natural gas, some of them may also run on liquid propane, while others are oil-fired. The following characteristics of Carrier furnaces:

• Up to 98.5% AFUE ratings, with the majority exceeding 90%
• Fixed, numerous, and variable speed blowers
• Models produced in accordance with Californian laws

Installation And Unit Costs

Prices vary depending on the chosen unit. Installation carries a fee. The cost rises in tandem with the efficiency rating. The cost of units with variable-speed motors is typically higher, regardless of their efficiency rating.

Air Conditioners

Payne:
A Payne air conditioner costs between $2,710 and $3,860, installation included. For example, the cost of a 1,601–1,900 square foot, 3-ton Payne central air conditioner before installation may be roughly $1,080.

Carrier:
There are several different air conditioning units available from Carrier. Depending on the model, the total price for buying and installing a Carrier unit might be anywhere between $4,500 and $10,700.

For the typical 1,800 square foot home, a 3-ton Carrier air conditioner would be required, and its installation would cost roughly $5,894.

Heat Pumps

Payne:
A heat pump typically costs between a few hundred dollars for a modest ductless system to $13,000 for the largest conventional heat pump, not including installation. Installation fees change based on the home’s size, location, and degree of difficulty.

Installation costs range from $4,300 for a small, entry-level Payne heat pump to over $10,000 for a large, 2-stage heat pump. Payne does not offer variable-capacity heat pumps, which can cost over $12,000.

Carrier:
Carrier heat pumps offer numerous comfort-improving technologies, acoustic ratings, and energy efficiency ratings including SEER and HSPF.

These enable the device to have installation costs of up to $15,000 (or more). The price of the unit is between $2,260 to $5,140.

Furnaces

Payne:
Payne, as opposed to other brands, can focus on what they do best and provide uncomplicated gas furnaces at affordable costs without a lot of complexity thanks to their small product portfolio.

Cheap units are an excellent option for usage in apartments and small homes and may be purchased for as little as $700 (maximum of $2700) if cost is the primary factor.

Even for their top, high-efficiency model, Payne offers fair price for a no-frills option to other gas furnaces on the market.

The cost to install a furnace can be anywhere between $1,970 and $3,330, with the majority of US houses typically spending less than $3,000 on installation.

Carrier:
The kind, features, size, and installation of a furnace from a Carrier affect its cost. The estimated cost of parts and installation for a Carrier gas furnace for a typical 1,800 square foot home using a 100,000 BTU heater is $3,100.

For the parts and installation of a Carrier oil furnace in a typical 1,800 square foot home, assuming a 250 gallon oil tank, you should set aside $5,100.

Warranties For Payne And Carrier

It is essential to take attention of the warranty for such a large purchase. The warranties are identical for Payne and Carrier.

Every product comes with the same 10-year limited components warranty after registration. You must register within 90 days of installation. If not, your warranty will expire after five years. Please consult the warranty certificate for a comprehensive list of details and restrictions.

To Sum Up

You should carefully weigh your options before deciding on the brand of cooling or heating equipment for your home.

By carefully choosing some of the greatest Payne and Carrier items, we have somewhat eased your workload. It’s crucial to make a list of your requirements, consider the characteristics, and choose a model that satisfies those requirements